Threats to Our Landscape Legacy Aren’t on Hold, and Neither Are We
Although the novel coronavirus has curtailed plans and events across the nation and the globe, TCLF’s advocacy work, under the banner of its Landslide program, has continued at a fast pace—and necessarily so, because the threats to our shared landscape legacy have continued as well. March was a month characterized by successful outcomes in that regard, including news that Garrett Eckbo’s Union Bank Plaza had been saved, and that work on Frederick Law Olmsted, Sr.’s, Staten Island Farm was moving forward after critical funds were raised to stabilize the property. And in April we relayed that the Fort Worth (Texas) City Council had approved $1 million for design work related to the rehabilitation of Heritage Park Plaza—very good news for the Modernist half-acre park designed by landscape architect Lawrence Halprin for the city’s U.S. Bicentennial Celebration in 1976.
But a new challenge appeared closer to home, in the nation’s capital, when TCLF learned about the potential destruction of MARABAR, the sculptural installation created by Elyn Zimmerman in the early 1980s for the campus of the National Geographic headquarters. We enrolled MARABAR in the Landslide program in late March, causing a string of letters to be sent to the District of Columbia’s Historic Preservation Review Board (HPRB) from prominent commentators who oppose the sculpture’s erasure, including Marc Treib, the well-known scholar and critic; Adam Weinberg, the director of the Whitney Museum of American Art; respected landscape architect Cheryl Barton; and David Childs, the chairman emeritus of Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, who was part of the project’s original design team. At its meeting on April 30, the HPRB acknowledged the public outcry and announced that it would “provide comments and direction” about the matter at an upcoming meeting on May 28, 2020.
TCLF also recently led the way to quickly draw attention to the plight of the McGinley Garden, a rare extant residential commission created by Ellen Shipman in 1925 in Milton, Massachusetts, not far from Boston. Despite being one of Shipman’s exemplary works executed at the zenith of her career, the landscape might soon be converted into an apartment complex with surface parking. Since we first brought the garden’s story to our readers, the Town of Milton has filed a letter opposing the new complex with MassHousing, which will make a decision on the building application in the coming weeks.
We also continue to advocate for the sound stewardship of the Hirshhorn Sculpture Garden in Washington, D.C. It has already taken months of effort and consultation to include the work of landscape architect Lester Collins within the garden’s Period of Significance, which was the first step in ensuring that his critically acclaimed redesign of the garden will not be obliterated by current plans. The next Section 106 review of impending changes to the garden has been scheduled for May 27, 2020. The meeting will take place online and will cover the draft Assessment of Effects, updates on the design of the “revitalization project,” and comments and questions from consulting parties.
The Section 106 review of the Obama Presidential Center (OPC) in Chicago’s Jackson Park is also heating up. After years of advocacy in the form of meetings, letters, and analyses, consulting parties will finally begin discussions with federal agencies on May 6, 2020, about how the OPC’s adverse effects on the Olmsted-designed park, which have now been documented, can be avoided, minimized, or mitigated. That process will continue during two subsequent meetings scheduled for May 20 and June 17.
Meanwhile, the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals is scheduled to hear oral arguments on May 21, 2020, in the lawsuit brought by Protect Our Parks (POP) against the Chicago Park District. The nonprofit POP is seeking to halt construction of the OPC, contending that the City of Chicago “abdicated and delegated its decision-making authority to a private party—the Obama Foundation—that operates without any public power, and has been wrongfully allowed to control and dominate this entire public project.”
We know that education and advocacy are important to our readers, and we continue to rely on your support as we commit the energy and countless hours of work—much of it behind the scenes—to achieve positive results in what are most often uphill battles. We’re also preparing our annual Landslide report for 2020, with the nomination period having just closed for Women Who Shaped the American Landscape, to be released later this year. In the meantime, all of our annual Landslide reports are viewable online, as are the myriad exhibitions that reside on our website, including The Landscape Architecture of Lawrence Halprin; The New American Garden; and The Landscape Architecture Legacy of Dan Kiley.
Now more than ever, we need your support as we continue to work toward positive outcomes for our shared landscape legacy.